Soneva Fushi in Baa Atoll

The biggest lie I've ever seen

I’ve been fortunate to stay at some of the world’s finest resorts globally and also in the Maldives – The Ritz, Four Seasons, One&Only, Como, Jumeirah, Six Senses – and rarely write reviews. I also hesitated with this given all the positive review but the readers should discern with all the info. Last year was a milestone birthday for us and we booked Soneva Fushi with great anticipation. This was a true “bucket list” stay. I’ve admired Sonu Shivdasani’s vision for years - since our first stay at Six Senses and expected something extraordinary. We arrived late last year 2024. The transfer flight from Malé was flawless and filled us with excitement. Unfortunately, the moment we stepped onto the island, the experience unraveled. Arrival & Welcome The welcome was among the worst we’ve ever experienced in the Maldives. The GM began greeting us, then abruptly walked away to take a phone call - which I over heard him telling off some poor staff member. Throughout our stay, his attitude was dismissive and distracted – more interested in his own dinner table than his guests. For a flagship property, this was shocking. Atmosphere & Grounds The island had a distinctly low-energy feel. “Rustic” here often crossed into “run-down.” The grounds were poorly maintained, some areas with odd smells, and the overall ambience felt tired rather than intentional. Villa We were placed in one of the new overwater villas – an enormous 4,500 sq ft space with a huge pool and slide - yes I know the pictures are wow. Impressive on paper, disappointing in reality. The pool had visible algae, furniture was worn, and the design felt more gimmicky than refined (sliding roof, awkwardly planned wardrobes, broken fittings). Even the basics – clean bedding and proper pillows – were lacking. Dining Our first dinner was one of the poorest we’ve had at any luxury property. A basic barbecue with below-average food quality, inconsistent drink service (the same cocktail arriving in different glasses), and a farmyard feel with chickens and rabbits running around the dining area. It felt chaotic, not curated. Service & Management To their credit, when we raised concerns, a couple of managers (not the GM) tried to help. But the issues were too fundamental – cleanliness, upkeep, energy of the island. None of it reflected the standard expected at this level and at the price they charge. Departure After One Night We had booked several nights but chose to leave after just one. My daughter even asked if we could go home – that’s how poor the atmosphere felt. Thankfully, our agent helped us transfer to Four Seasons Landaa Giraavaru, where we spent the rest of our stay and immediately felt the difference. The Four Seasons team was warm, genuine, and attentive. Not more “luxurious,” just simply better in every way that matters our trip was saved and was memorable. Final Thoughts I cannot understand how Soneva Fushi continues to win “best resort” accolades. Perhaps on reputation, b