I have been a devoted guest at Capofaro since 2018, returning year after year for its unique blend of tranquility, beauty, and what used to be truly exceptional service. I have even celebrated major milestones here, including once privatizing the entire hotel for my birthday. It is with great sadness that I write this review after my summer 2025 stay, which has been nothing short of a disappointment and has, frankly, ruined my holiday. Chronic Understaffing and Inexperience From the moment I arrived, it was obvious the hotel is chronically understaffed. Housekeeping and restaurant teams are stretched to the limit, and nearly every staff member I spoke to admitted they had only been working here for two months or less. There is no sign of the seasoned, professional staff who once made Capofaro special. Instead, confusion reigns, and the lack of training is evident in everything from basic politeness to the ability to handle guest requests. Restaurant: Monotonous Menu and Rigid, Unhelpful Rules The lunch menu has not changed once during my entire stay—just the same four entrées, every single day. For a hotel that claims to be a gastronomic destination, this is simply unacceptable. How is a long-staying guest expected to eat the same food daily? Worse, the restaurant operates under a set of inflexible rules that seem designed to frustrate guests. On our first day, a large, noisy group on a wine tour made the dining room unbearable. We asked to have our lunch in the quiet bar area—there were no other guests, and it was the end of service—but were told this was “against the rules.” In the past, such a reasonable request would have been granted without hesitation. It’s clear the staff have no discretion or authority to make guests comfortable. Service Failures: No Attention to Detail, No Desire to Please The little touches that once made Capofaro feel special are gone. When we asked for milk for tea in our room, it took over an hour to arrive—and came with a €25 service charge plus €5 for a single cup of milk. Despite repeated requests, milk was never replenished in the room, a basic amenity even at a four-star hotel. Housekeeping is unreliable: sometimes there is an evening turndown, sometimes not. Glasses and cups are not replaced daily, so we found ourselves unable to enjoy a simple coffee or drink in the room. Tissue boxes and water bottles are not restocked without repeated reminders, and during a heatwave, waiting endlessly for water is simply unacceptable. Front Desk: Untrained, Rude, and Unempathetic The front desk is manned by a single, very young staff member who has also only been here for two months. When I requested a late checkout—just two hours, to accommodate my pregnant partner in the 40° Sicilian heat—I was met with a curt “not possible,” with no attempt to understand our situation or offer any alternatives. This lack of empathy and flexibility is shocking for a hotel charging €1,000 per night. Management: Completely Ab

We visited the Capofaro Locando & Malvasia for 3 nights in early September. We were told that our room was being upgraded and were assigned a “Capofaro” (lighthouse) room with a roof patio with no chairs. There were no water views from inside the room. The chairs on our garden patio did not have the necessary cushions put on them. With this, we felt that we were captive to the inside of the room or the resort’s common areas. The dinner in the restaurant the first night was exceptional. The shuttle service offered to a couple of villages on Salina was timely and well run. As is customary in Italy, breakfast is included with an accommodation. The breakfast offerings at Capofaro was very disappointing. Eggs were not offered unless you asked and anything other than scrambled, fried, or poached eggs were offered at a stiff up charge. The fruit offerings were minimal. Services were also lacking. We requested ice for our room twice. The first time, it took 45 minutes to get ice. The second time, it never came. My wife asked the person making up the room for an extra bath towel for her hair. Our expectation is that it would be repeated daily. It was not.