The William Hotel Midtown, New York in New York

I'm from the West Coast, so I only come here on business travel, but this is the only place I eat when staying at the Grand Hyatt (just upstairs). West Coast flights don't arrive any earlier than 4pm, so I have only done dinner here, and usually not before 7pm. I have been here at least two dozen times since 2000.

The seafood is always fresh, and the menu variety is huge. They do run out of a few things by 7pm, but I have never had to resort to my third choice, ever.

The best option is the four horseshoe tables in the middle that seat about 20 people each on barstools---the server HAS to walk past you all the time, so there is never any frustration wondering where he/she is. Yes, there are some characters, but never rude.

This place mostly serves commuters waiting on their trains, so nobody hangs out much after their meal is over. That frees up seats.

It isn't cheap, but it isn't as expensive as most seafood joints in midtown. Good value and you won't leave hungry.

It is historic, and that is a plus. They have a very old seafood stew bar that uses piped steam to make seafood stews from fresh ingredients that you choose in four different copper/brass vessels right on the bar. Very Old School, and very delicious.

Something for everyone!

The seeded crackers and soda rolls are absolutely unique and delicious!

Grand Central was so busy that I thought there would be no way we could get into a restaurant. We walked up to the Oyster Bar and it is so big that there were a few options. We tried the first main seating section and it was full, then there were a few scattered seats at the bars but not two together. We went to the Saloon and while still very busy the host found us a table without any wait. This is a noisy place so if you're looking for a quiet place to talk, try elsewhere but it's a great group gathering. I ordered the jumbo shrimp with steamed herbed potatoes and they were all yummy! My husband had the clam chowder and an appetizer. While not the best old fashioned cocktails we've ever had it was still good and I'd gladly return. It hosts a melting pot of people and I felt like this Colorado girl was definitely in NYC!

Always great. The menu is awesome, so much to choose from. I just love the space and the staff is always good. Oysters are always a must along with the clam chowder. My broiled arctic char was super fresh.

Nice ambiance very quaint and unexpected in the middle of grand central! I sat at the bar and only wanted oysters.. my waiter said no problem and gave me an assortment from all over.. they were so fresh and tasty ...I'm glad I made the trip. Will definitely go many times again!

Update:
On 7/1/17 I had to bring my parents visiting from Florida here!!! We had such an awesome time!!! Muhammad was our server and he went above and beyond to provide world class service! This my favorite place for oysters in NY and the lobster was amazing!

Great customer service and location is fast paced which is great for me who is on the go a lot

Great soup~! Reasonable price.

I had brunch here early December. There was no way I can reserve a seat through opentable (indicated there was no availability) so we were there around 11ish. There was maybe 2 people before us waiting to be seated once the place opened. They seated us right next to the Christmas tree - what a treat! Brunch was good - I really enjoyed their assortment of pastries. My glass of rose had something floating in it so they got me a new glass. It was overall a good experience.

Accommodated our request for a table in Garden (for 8 people). The table change was seamless.....food great tasting... served timely... Portions adequate .... Service was white table cloth and linen napkins.... Water and drink refills were serviced without fuss. This was a family celebration dinner, and it could not have been nicer.... Another family member suggested we go to this restaurant and we were glad they did.... We will be back!
We had chicken, pork, fish and steak frites dishes, no complaints.... from anyone!

Amazing place. It was an honor and a privilege being here for our annual Holiday Party with my coworkers. This place for this year’s holiday party was a perfect choice. There’s a large area to dance. The staff is friendly. Food was tasty & delicious. Near to public transportation.

Came here for birthday dinner evening before the parade. Wasn't expecting much as chose for location but was pleasantly surprised. Food was excellent and was super kid friendly. Will return. Thanks for making my evening special